This post contains affiliate links. By clicking on a product link and making a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting The Banana Diaries!
Step into autumn with a touch of nostalgia and a whole lot of deliciousness! These copycat Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies are incredibly soft, delightfully chewy, and possess a taste and texture so uncannily similar to the classic, you’ll be amazed. Best of all, they’re crafted from the simplest slice-and-bake cookie dough and are entirely free of eggs and dairy, making them a perfect vegan treat for the fall season.
You’ll Never Believe These Easy Copycat Pillsbury Pumpkin Sugar Cookies Are Vegan!
For many of us, the sight of Pillsbury’s holiday sugar cookies brings a rush of childhood memories. Who can forget the pure joy of biting into that raw, sweet dough before it even hit the oven? The iconic pumpkin shapes appearing as if by magic on a cold autumn day were a quintessential part of growing up. However, for those of us embracing a vegan lifestyle or dealing with egg and dairy sensitivities, that cherished tradition seemed to be a thing of the past.
That is, until now. I embarked on a mission to recreate the beloved Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookie in a way that everyone could enjoy. The challenge was to achieve that exact soft, chewy texture and unmistakable flavor profile without any animal products. After much experimentation, I can confidently say the results are truly uncanny. These homemade vegan pumpkin sugar cookies are not just “good for vegan” – they are genuinely *identical* to the classic Pillsbury holiday sugar cookie in every delightful way.
What makes these copycat vegan pumpkin cookies even more remarkable is their simplicity. We achieve this incredible flavor and texture using just a handful of basic ingredients – a mere six, to be precise! You won’t find any palm oil or canola oil here, either. Instead, we utilize a clever trick that I also employ in my classic vegan sugar cookies and vegan drop style sugar cookies to ensure a perfect bake every time.
These versatile cookies are fantastic baked as individual treats, or you can even get creative! Take inspiration from the viral chocolate chip cookie Pillsbury cookie mega cookie trend by using my Better Than Tollhouse Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies as a delicious base for an epic cookie creation. The possibilities are endless for enjoying these delightful fall-themed treats!
Decoding the Classic: How We Achieved Pillsbury’s Iconic Flavor (The Vegan Way)
To truly replicate the beloved Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies, it was essential to understand the original formula. The ingredients for the classic Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies, as listed on their website, typically include:
“Enriched Flour Bleached (wheat flour, niacin, iron, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), Sugar, Palm Oil, Water, Canola Oil. Contains 2% or less of: Eggs, Baking Powder (sodium aluminum phosphate, baking soda), Salt, Yellow 5 & 6, Artificial Flavor, Blue 1, Sodium Benzoate (preservative).” – Pillsbury website.
Upon closer inspection, the core components are quite straightforward: **flour, sugar, palm oil, water, canola oil, eggs, baking powder, salt, food coloring, and artificial flavor.** Our goal was to achieve the same taste and texture without the eggs, palm oil, canola oil, or artificial flavors, while still keeping the recipe accessible and simple.
The good news is that eggs are surprisingly not essential for achieving that characteristic chewy sugar cookie texture. And by making thoughtful substitutions, we can bypass palm and canola oils entirely. Through careful selection and combination of just six fundamental ingredients, we’ve successfully recreated the iconic flavor profile, proving that incredible taste doesn’t require a long list of complex additives or artificial enhancers. Here’s a closer look at the stars of our vegan pumpkin cookie show:
The Simple Six: Key Ingredients for Vegan Pillsbury Pumpkin Cookies
- All-Purpose Flour: The foundation of any great cookie! We stick with classic all-purpose flour for consistency and a tender crumb. If you’re outside the U.S., this is often referred to as plain flour. For those seeking a gluten-free option, a 1:1 gluten-free baking flour blend will work, but ensure it contains xanthan gum for proper structure. My personal recommendation, based on extensive testing, is King Arthur Measure for Measure; I’ve found it yields the most reliable results compared to other brands like Bob’s Red Mill in this particular recipe.
- Organic Powdered Sugar (Confectioners’ Sugar): This is a secret weapon for achieving that melt-in-your-mouth texture that sets these cookies apart. Unlike granulated sugar, powdered sugar incorporates much more evenly into the dough, leading to a smoother, more tender cookie. Furthermore, powdered sugar often contains cornstarch, which contributes to the delightful pillowy softness we’re aiming for. This tip, passed down from my childhood best friend’s mom, is a game-changer for sugar cookies!
- Vegan Butter: Our delicious substitute for palm and canola oils. The quality of your vegan butter significantly impacts the final flavor. For the closest taste to Pillsbury’s richness, I highly recommend Miyoko’s Kitchen Cultured Vegan Butter (especially the sea salt variety – it’s incredibly delicious!). However, if you have nut allergies or prefer another brand, Plant Crock also works wonderfully. Ensure your vegan butter is at room temperature for optimal creaming.
- Baking Powder: Just a touch of baking powder is all we need to give these cookies a subtle lift, preventing them from becoming too dense and contributing to their soft chewiness without excessive puff.
- Dairy-Free Milk: A tablespoon or two is all that’s required to bring the dough together. The goal is to achieve a cohesive, workable dough without making it too wet. Over-adding milk can lead to cookies spreading too much in the oven, losing their defined pumpkin shape. Almond milk, soy milk, or oat milk are all great choices.
- Sea Salt & Vanilla Extract: While technically two ingredients, I always categorize these as essential flavor enhancers rather than core components. They are simple staples you likely have on hand, playing a crucial role in deepening the overall flavor profile and balancing the sweetness. A good quality vanilla extract elevates these cookies from good to truly exceptional.
Why Choose Vegan Pillsbury Pumpkin Sugar Cookies?
Beyond simply replicating a beloved classic, opting for a vegan version of these pumpkin sugar cookies offers several compelling benefits:
- Allergen-Friendly: For those with egg or dairy allergies or sensitivities, these cookies open up a world of safe and delicious indulgence. No more missing out on holiday treats!
- Dietary Inclusivity: Hosting a gathering? These vegan cookies ensure that guests with various dietary preferences – whether vegan, lactose-intolerant, or simply opting for plant-based choices – can all enjoy the festive spirit together.
- Ethical Choice: Choosing vegan means supporting animal welfare and opting for a more compassionate approach to baking.
- Surprisingly Delicious: Many are often surprised by how incredibly rich, flavorful, and satisfying vegan baked goods can be. These cookies are a testament to that, proving that plant-based doesn’t mean compromising on taste or texture.
- No Artificial Flavors or Oils: Our recipe skips the artificial flavors and highly processed palm and canola oils found in the original, offering a cleaner, yet equally delicious, alternative.
In Britt’s Kitchen: My Guide to Vibrant Vegan Food Coloring
One of the signature charms of Pillsbury’s holiday cookies is their vibrant, cheerful colors. Replicating this in a vegan recipe, especially with the added challenge of baking, has been a journey of trial and error for me. Many plant-based food colorings, while wonderful for frostings, tend to fade significantly when subjected to oven heat. This fading is a major hurdle when trying to achieve those beautifully distinct orange and green pumpkin shapes.
After years of testing and countless batches of cookies, I’ve compiled my top recommendations for vegan food colorings that truly stand up to baking. Here are several options to help you achieve those perfectly vibrant Pillsbury-esque hues:
- Whole Foods 365 Brand with an Alternate Red Coloring: The yellow and blue from the Whole Foods 365 brand are generally reliable for creating a good green. However, their red often fades too much during baking. For a truly vibrant orange, I recommend pairing their yellow with an alternative, more robust vegan red food coloring.
- Ann Clark Food Coloring Gels: I have a strong affinity for this brand. While not plant-based in their base ingredients, they are vegan certified, meaning they are cruelty-free and do not contain animal products. The colors produced by Ann Clark gels are incredibly vibrant and bake beautifully. This is my go-to recommendation for a powerful red to complement the Whole Foods yellow when aiming for that perfect pumpkin orange.
- Suncore Foods Superfood Powders: If you’re committed to all-natural, plant-derived colorants, superfood powders are an excellent choice. This method requires a bit more finesse and patience to incorporate into the dough, but the results are stunningly beautiful. Be mindful that these powders might impart a subtle flavor to your cookies. For orange, I suggest a blend of beet powder and turmeric or sweet potato powder. For a natural green, emerald pandan leaf powder works wonders. Experiment with small amounts to achieve your desired shade.
- Sweetapolita Gels: Sweetapolita is already a favorite of mine for their fantastic vegan sprinkles, and their recently launched food coloring gels are just as impressive! They are specifically formulated to be vegan and offer vibrant, bake-stable colors. The best part? They often have pre-mixed orange and green gels, eliminating the need for you to combine colors yourself – a convenient time-saver!
Once you’ve chosen your coloring, the key to even distribution is working it into the dough thoroughly. I recommend wearing food-safe gloves and kneading the color into the dough much like you would playdough. Continuously squish and fold the dough until the color is uniformly vibrant throughout. This ensures no streaks or uneven patches in your final baked cookies.
Crafting the Perfect Pumpkin: How to Shape Your Vegan Sugar Cookies
For a comprehensive guide with precise ingredient measurements and detailed written instructions, please refer to the recipe card at the conclusion of this post. You can also quickly jump to the recipe by clicking the “jump to recipe” button located at the top of the page. Here, we’ll provide a concise overview of the steps, accompanied by helpful visuals, to give you a clear understanding of the pumpkin shaping process.
For a visual demonstration of how to expertly craft these charming pumpkin cookies, you can watch my dedicated video tutorial here.
Creative Uses for Extra Dough Scraps
After carefully cutting out all your charming pumpkin shapes, you might find yourself with a few leftover dough scraps. Don’t let them go to waste! All three colored doughs (vanilla, orange, and green) can be easily gathered, re-rolled, and cut into additional cookies. You can combine them for a fun marbled effect, or simply bake them as plain sugar cookies. I always try to maximize the orange and green dough to yield as many of those iconic Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies as possible. In my experience during recipe testing, this usually leaves just a tablespoon or two of plain vanilla dough leftover at most, perfect for a quick snack or a tiny bonus cookie!
Expert Tips for Flawless Vegan Pumpkin Sugar Cookies
Achieving bakery-perfect results with your homemade cookies is easier than you think, especially with a few insider tips:
- Precision in Measuring Flour: Always spoon and level your flour, rather than scooping directly from the bag. Scooping can pack down the flour, leading to too much dry ingredient and a dense, dry cookie.
- Room Temperature Vegan Butter: This is critical! Your vegan butter should be soft enough to easily indent with a finger, but not melted. This allows it to cream properly with the sugar, creating an airy texture that prevents spreading.
- Don’t Overmix the Dough: Once the flour is added, mix only until just combined. Overmixing develops the gluten, resulting in tougher cookies.
- The Importance of Chilling: Do not skip the chilling steps! Chilling the dough solidifies the fat, preventing the cookies from spreading excessively in the oven and helping them maintain their intricate pumpkin shape.
- Even Thickness for Slicing: When slicing the final log of dough, aim for consistent 1/4-inch to 1/3-inch thickness. This ensures even baking and uniform texture across all your cookies.
- Baking Sheet Preparation: Always line your baking sheets with parchment paper or a silicone baking mat. This prevents sticking and ensures easy cleanup.
- Oven Temperature Accuracy: An oven thermometer is a great investment! Ovens can vary widely, and accurate temperature is key for consistent baking results.
Troubleshooting Common Cookie Issues
Even experienced bakers can run into a snag or two. Here are quick fixes for common problems:
- Cookies Spreading Too Much: This usually means your dough wasn’t chilled enough, or your vegan butter was too soft. Try chilling the dough for an additional 30-60 minutes, or even a quick 15-minute freeze. Ensure your oven is fully preheated.
- Dough is Too Crumbly: If your dough won’t come together, add dairy-free milk one teaspoon at a time until it’s cohesive but not sticky. Different brands of vegan butter or flour can absorb liquids differently.
- Cookies are Too Hard/Dry: This often indicates overmixing or baking for too long. Ensure you’re measuring flour correctly and pulling cookies from the oven when edges are just barely golden, even if the centers seem slightly soft. They will continue to set as they cool.
- Colors Fading: As discussed in the food coloring section, this is common with some plant-based dyes. Refer to my guide for recommended bake-stable vegan food colorings.
Storage and Make-Ahead Tips
These vegan Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies are perfect for making ahead, ensuring you always have a batch of festive treats ready to go!
- Storing Raw Dough: The prepared cookie dough log can be tightly wrapped in plastic wrap and stored in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks. For longer storage, you can freeze the log for up to 3 months. When ready to bake, thaw the frozen dough in the refrigerator overnight before slicing and baking as usual.
- Storing Baked Cookies: Once baked and completely cooled, store the cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5-7 days. To maintain their freshness and chewy texture, you can add a slice of bread to the container – the cookies will absorb moisture from the bread.
- Freezing Baked Cookies: Baked cookies can also be frozen for up to 3 months. Arrange cooled cookies in a single layer on a baking sheet to freeze solid, then transfer them to an airtight freezer-safe bag or container, layered with parchment paper to prevent sticking. Thaw at room temperature before serving.
Want to save this recipe for later? Add it to your favorite recipe board on Pinterest!
If you make this irresistible recipe, please be sure to leave a comment and a rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ below. Your feedback helps others discover these amazing cookies! As always, I absolutely adore seeing your beautiful creations, so be sure to tag me @the_bananadiaries on Instagram and Pinterest!
Print
Easy Copycat Vegan Pillsbury Pumpkin Sugar Cookies
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star
5 from 8 reviews
Author: Britt Berlin
Prep Time: 45
Chilling Time: 180
Cook Time: 15
Total Time: 4 hours
Yield: 24 1x
Category: Cookies
Method: Baking
Cuisine: American
Diet: Vegan
Description
Soft, chewy, and quite literally identical in taste and texture, these copycat Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies are made with the simplest slice n’ bake cookie dough, and no eggs nor dairy is needed!
Ingredients
Scale
Cookie Dough:
- 1 cup (226 g) vegan butter, room temperature
- 2 cups (240 g) organic powdered sugar
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 1 tsp baking powder
- 1/4 tsp sea salt
- 2 1/2 cups (313 g) all purpose flour*
- 1–2 tbsp dairy free milk
- 1 pea-sized drop vegan red food coloring*
- 4–7 drops vegan yellow food coloring, divided*
- 1–2 drops vegan blue food coloring*
Equipment:
- 1.5″ pumpkin cookie cutter*
- large bowl
- 2 small bowls
- Whisk or hand mixer
- Silicone spatula
- Plastic wrap or parchment paper
Instructions
- Prep: Begin by accurately measuring all your ingredients, with the exception of the food coloring. It’s always a good idea to read through the entire recipe instructions before you start. If you don’t have a pumpkin cookie cutter, don’t worry! Consult the “Notes” section below for alternative shaping instructions.
- Make the dough: In a spacious large bowl, use either a whisk or a hand mixer to cream the room-temperature vegan butter until it achieves a light and fluffy consistency, a process that should take about 1-2 minutes. Next, incorporate the powdered sugar, vanilla extract, baking powder, and sea salt. Mix thoroughly until all ingredients are well combined and the mixture resembles a smooth buttercream frosting. Gradually add in the all-purpose flour, followed by 1 tablespoon of dairy-free milk. Using a silicone spatula, gently fold the flour into the wet ingredients. Add the second tablespoon of dairy-free milk only if the dough is still too dry and crumbly to come together. The dough may require a little effort to fully incorporate, which is perfectly normal; it will eventually form a cohesive ball.
- Color the dough: Divide your prepared dough into two equal halves. Then, take one of those halves and divide it in half again, resulting in two quarter-sized portions of dough. Remove one of these quarter portions and place it into a small bowl (this will be designated for the orange food coloring). Now, take the remaining quarter portion and divide it in half once more, placing this smaller, eighth-sized portion into another small bowl (this will be for the green food coloring). The large bowl should now contain half of the original dough batch plus one-eighth of the dough, which will remain plain (vanilla).
- Orange: To the bowl containing the quarter portion of dough, add 1 drop of vegan red food coloring and 3-4 drops of vegan yellow food coloring. For best results, wear food-safe gloves and mix the coloring into the dough by kneading it like play dough. While a spoon or spatula can be used, it will take considerably more time to achieve an evenly distributed color. Adjust the amount of coloring to reach your desired shade.
- Green: Into the bowl with the eighth portion of cookie dough, add 1 drop of vegan blue food coloring and 3-4 drops of vegan yellow food coloring. Again, use food-safe gloves to thoroughly mix the coloring into the dough, working it like play dough. As with the orange dough, using a spoon or spatula will require more effort to achieve even coloration. Feel free to adjust the amount of coloring to your preference.
- Wrap and chill the cookie dough: Carefully wrap each portion of cookie dough (vanilla, orange, and green) separately in plastic wrap, forming flattened discs. Place all wrapped dough into the refrigerator and chill for a minimum of 2 hours. This chilling period is crucial for the dough to firm up, making it easier to handle and preventing excessive spreading during baking.
- Form the pumpkin log: Remove all the chilled cookie dough from the refrigerator. Set aside the vanilla cookie dough to rest at room temperature while you work with the colored doughs. For the orange and green doughs, you’ll be forming logs that will be used with your 1.5″ pumpkin cookie cutter. Take the orange cookie dough and carefully shape it into a long log, approximately 1/2″ wide and 1 1/4″ in height (around 10-12 inches in length). It should have a somewhat flattened, elongated shape. Use a rolling pin to smooth the top surface (refer to the video for visual guidance). Next, take the green dough and shape it into a similar long log, about 1/2″ thick, but this time, only about 1/4-1/2″ in height (also around 10-12 inches in length). Align the green cookie dough log precisely along the top edge of the orange cookie dough log, creating one larger, combined log with distinct green and orange sections.
- Cut the pumpkin cookies: Now, take your pumpkin cookie cutter. Begin to cut out the pumpkin cookie shapes along the length of the combined log. Carefully align the stem of the pumpkin cutter with the green dough and the main pumpkin body with the orange dough. As you cut each pumpkin cookie, stack them neatly on top of each other, either tall or lengthwise (refer to the blog photos or video for guidance on stacking). Any leftover dough scraps can be gently reformed into a smaller orange and green log, allowing you to cut out additional cookies. You can also use small scraps to fill any gaps or better align the stems of the pumpkins, being careful to maintain the overall pumpkin shape. Once all the dough is used up, meticulously wrap the entire log of pumpkin cookie cutouts in one of the spare plastic wrap pieces. Place this wrapped log into the freezer to chill for 20 minutes; this helps set the shapes before the final wrapping.
- Roll out the vanilla cookie dough: While your pumpkin cookie log is firming up in the freezer, turn your attention to the vanilla cookie dough. Lay the plastic wrap from the vanilla dough flat on your work surface. To prevent sticking, you can place another piece of plastic wrap (perhaps from one of the discarded colored dough discs) on top of the vanilla dough before rolling. Roll the vanilla dough into a large, even rectangle, approximately 12″ long by 4-5″ wide. Once rolled, remove the top plastic wrap piece and set it aside or discard. We will now strategically slice the vanilla dough to perfectly encase the pumpkin cookies.
- Finish shaping the Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies: Retrieve the pumpkin sugar cookies from the freezer. Carefully place the chilled pumpkin log onto the center of the rolled-out vanilla cookie dough, aligning their lengths. Gently lift each side of the vanilla cookie dough and practice wrapping it around the pumpkin cookies to see where the dough will overlap. Using a sharp knife, carefully slice off the overlapping excess pieces of vanilla dough. Roll these trimmed pieces into two thin, 12″ long logs. Place these logs precisely on either side of the green pumpkin stems, pressing them gently into the pumpkin shapes. This step is crucial for transforming the pumpkins into one large, uniform cylinder, ensuring the integrity of the stem when the entire log is rolled. Finally, carefully wrap the vanilla cookie dough over the pumpkin sugar cookies, gently rolling the entire log so that the vanilla dough adheres firmly to the pumpkin cookies, forming one cohesive large log. Wrap this finished log securely in fresh plastic wrap and return it to the refrigerator to chill for another 30 minutes to 1 hour. This final chill is vital for setting the complete cookie structure before slicing.
- While the dough is chilling: During the final chilling period, preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). Line two large baking sheets with parchment paper, preparing them for your delicious cookies.
- Slice the cookies: Once the chilling is complete, remove the cookie dough log from the refrigerator. Using a sharp knife, slice the log into uniform 1/4″ to 1/3″ thick cookie rounds. Arrange these sliced cookies onto the prepared baking sheets, ensuring they are spaced about 2″ apart to allow for proper airflow and slight spreading during baking.
- Bake: Place the baking sheets into your preheated oven and bake for approximately 12-14 minutes, or until the edges of the cookies are lightly golden. The centers may still appear slightly soft, but they will firm up as they cool. Remove the cookies from the oven and allow them to cool on the baking sheets for 5-10 minutes before transferring them to a wire rack to cool completely.
- Enjoy! Savor your homemade copycat Pillsbury pumpkin sugar cookies! Any leftover dough can be stored, well-wrapped, in the fridge for up to 2 weeks or in the freezer for up to 3 months. Baked cookies can be stored in an airtight container at room temperature for up to a week.
Equipment
cookie sheet
Buy Now →
rolling pin
Buy Now →
Notes
Food coloring: For detailed insights and recommendations on the best vegan food colors that hold their vibrancy during baking, please refer to the comprehensive guide within the main blog post.
Pumpkin cookie cutter alternative: If you prefer not to purchase a pumpkin cookie cutter, you can still achieve charming pumpkin shapes. Roll the orange cookie dough into a large, 12-inch oblong log (think of a semi-flat cylinder, similar to the natural shape of a pumpkin). Using a skewer or the dull edge of a knife, gently press an indent along the top center of this oblong log. Next, roll the green cookie dough into a separate 12-inch long log. Carefully place this green log into the indent you created on the orange dough. Once combined, wrap the entire cookie dough log securely in plastic wrap and freeze it until firm. You can then slice this log to reveal your homemade pumpkin cookies.
Gluten free: For a successful gluten-free version of these cookies, I highly recommend using King Arthur Measure for Measure gluten-free flour blend. It consistently yields the best texture and structure in this recipe.